First quantization: Difference between revisions
en>Cesaranieto |
en>Hyuga m →Theoretical background: fixed slightly awkward "the" before "Schroedinger's" |
||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
In [[logic]], a '''tautology''' (from the [[Greek language|Greek]] word ταυτολογία) is a [[well-formed formula|formula]] which is true in every possible [[interpretation (logic)|interpretation]]. [[Philosopher]] [[Ludwig Wittgenstein]] first applied the term to redundancies of [[propositional logic]] in 1921; (it had been used earlier to refer to [[tautology (rhetoric)|rhetorical tautologies]], and continues to be used in that alternate sense). | |||
A formula is [[Satisfiability and validity|satisfiable]] if it is true under at least one interpretation, and thus a tautology is a formula whose negation is unsatisfiable. Unsatisfiable statements, both through negation and affirmation, are known formally as [[contradiction]]s. A formula that is neither a tautology nor a contradiction is said to be [[Contingency (philosophy)|logically contingent]]. Such a formula can be made either true or false based on the values assigned to its propositional variables. The [[double turnstile]] notation <math>\vDash S</math> is used to indicate that ''S'' is a tautology. Tautology is sometimes symbolized by "V''pq''", and contradiction by "O''pq''". The [[tee (symbol)|tee]] symbol <math>\top</math> is sometimes used to denote an arbitrary tautology, with the dual symbol <math>\bot</math> ([[falsum]]) representing an arbitrary contradiction. | |||
Tautologies are a key concept in [[propositional logic]], where a tautology is defined as a propositional formula that is true under any possible Boolean valuation of its [[propositional variable]]s. A key property of tautologies in propositional logic is that an [[effective method]] exists for testing whether a given formula is always satisfied (or, equivalently, whether its negation is unsatisfiable). | |||
The definition of ''tautology'' can be extended to sentences in [[predicate logic]], which may contain [[Quantification|quantifiers]], unlike sentences of propositional logic. In propositional logic, there is no distinction between a tautology and a [[Validity|logically valid]] formula. In the context of [[predicate logic]], many authors define a tautology to be a sentence that can be obtained by taking a tautology of propositional logic and uniformly replacing each propositional variable by a first-order formula (one formula per propositional variable). The set of such formulas is a [[proper subset]] of the set of logically valid sentences of predicate logic (which are the sentences that are true in every [[structure (mathematical logic)|model]]). | |||
==History== | |||
The word ''tautology'' was used by the ancient Greeks to describe a statement that was true merely by virtue of saying the same thing twice, a pejorative meaning that is still used for [[tautology (rhetoric)|rhetorical tautologies]]. Between 1800 and 1940, the word gained new meaning in logic, and is currently used in [[mathematical logic]] to denote a certain type of propositional formula, without the pejorative connotations it originally possessed.<!-- remainder of this section sourced to Dreben and Floyd; will add more sources later. | |||
Logical positivism became an issue according to Dr.Kowalsky and Dr.Rodgers since it held as neither a tautology nor empirically verifiable. Due to this issue it was in fact excluded from further definitions of science by those that followed in the philosophical scientific footsteps. Despite this there are still scientists today that feel that logical positivism (relying mainly on tautology) is still valid. | |||
--> | |||
In 1800, [[Immanuel Kant]] wrote in his book ''Logic'': | |||
:"The identity of concepts in analytical judgments can be either ''explicit'' (''explicita'') or ''non-explicit'' (''implicita''). In the former case analytic propositions are ''tautological.''" | |||
Here ''analytic proposition'' refers to an [[analytic truth]], a statement in natural language that is true solely because of the terms involved. | |||
In [ | In 1884, [[Gottlob Frege]] proposed in his ''Grundlagen'' that a truth is analytic exactly if it can be derived using logic. But he maintained a distinction between analytic truths (those true based only on the meanings of their terms) and tautologies (statements devoid of content). | ||
In 1921, in his ''[[Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus]]'', Ludwig Wittgenstein proposed that statements that can be deduced by logical deduction are tautological (empty of meaning) as well as being analytic truths. [[Henri Poincaré]] had made similar remarks in ''Science and Hypothesis'' in 1905. Although [[Bertrand Russell]] at first argued against these remarks by Wittgenstein and Poincaré, claiming that mathematical truths were not only non-tautologous but were [[synthetic truth|synthetic]], he later spoke in favor of them in 1918: | |||
:"Everything that is a proposition of logic has got to be in some sense or the other like a tautology. It has got to be something that has some peculiar quality, which I do not know how to define, that belongs to logical propositions but not to others." | |||
Here ''logical proposition'' refers to a proposition that is provable using the laws of logic. | |||
During the 1930s, the formalization of the semantics of propositional logic in terms of truth assignments was developed. The term ''tautology'' began to be applied to those propositional formulas that are true regardless of the truth or falsity of their propositional variables. Some early books on logic (such as ''Symbolic Logic'' by [[C. I. Lewis]] and Langford, 1932) used the term for any proposition (in any formal logic) that is universally valid. It is common in presentations after this (such as [[Stephen Kleene]] 1967 and [[Herbert Enderton]] 2002) to use ''tautology'' to refer to a logically valid propositional formula, but to maintain a distinction between ''tautology'' and ''logically valid'' in the context of first-order logic (see [[Tautology_%28logic%29#Tautologies_versus_validities_in_first-order_logic|below]]). | |||
== | ==Background== | ||
{{Main|propositional logic}} | |||
Propositional logic begins with '''propositional variables''', atomic units that represent concrete propositions. A '''formula''' consists of propositional variables connected by logical connectives in a meaningful way, so that the truth of the overall formula can be uniquely deduced from the truth or falsity of each variable. A '''valuation''' is a function that assigns each propositional variable either T (for truth) or F (for falsity). So, for example, using the propositional variables ''A'' and ''B'', the binary connectives <math>\lor</math> and <math>\land</math> representing [[Logical disjunction|disjunction]] and [[Logical conjunction|conjunction]] respectively, and the unary connective <math>\lnot</math> representing [[negation]], the following formula can be obtained::<math>(A \land B) \lor (\lnot A) \lor (\lnot B)</math>. | |||
A valuation here must assign to each of ''A'' and ''B'' either T or F. But no matter how this assignment is made, the overall formula will come out true. For if the first conjunction <math>(A \land B)</math> is not satisfied by a particular valuation, then one of ''A'' and ''B'' is assigned F, which will cause the corresponding later disjunct to be T. | |||
== | ==Definition and examples== | ||
A formula of propositional logic is a '''tautology''' if the formula itself is always true regardless of which valuation is used for the propositional variables. | |||
There are infinitely many tautologies. Examples include: | |||
*<math>(A \lor \lnot A)</math> ("''A'' or not ''A''"), the [[law of the excluded middle]]. This formula has only one propositional variable, ''A''. Any valuation for this formula must, by definition, assign ''A'' one of the truth values ''true'' or ''false'', and assign <math>\lnot</math>''A'' the other truth value. | |||
*<math>(A \to B) \Leftrightarrow (\lnot B \to \lnot A)</math> ("if ''A'' implies ''B'' then not-''B'' implies not-''A''", and vice versa), which expresses the law of [[contraposition]]. | |||
*<math>((\lnot A \to B) \land (\lnot A \to \lnot B)) \to A</math> ("if not-''A'' implies both ''B'' and its negation not-''B'', then not-''A'' must be false, then ''A'' must be true"), which is the principle known as ''[[reductio ad absurdum]]''. | |||
*<math>\lnot(A \land B) \Leftrightarrow (\lnot A \lor \lnot B)</math> ("if not both ''A'' and ''B'', then either not-''A'' or not-''B''", and vice versa), which is known as [[de Morgan's law]]. | |||
*<math>((A \to B) \land (B \to C)) \to (A \to C)</math> ("if ''A'' implies ''B'' and ''B'' implies ''C'', then ''A'' implies ''C''"), which is the principle known as [[syllogism]]. | |||
*<math>((A \lor B) \land (A \to C) \land (B \to C)) \to C</math> (if at least one of ''A'' or ''B'' is true, and each implies ''C'', then ''C'' must be true as well), which is the principle known as [[proof by cases]]. | |||
A minimal tautology is a tautology that is not the instance of a shorter tautology. | |||
*<math>(A \or B) \to (A \or B)</math> is a tautology, but not a minimal one, because it is an instantiation of <math>C \to C</math>. | |||
==Verifying tautologies== | |||
The problem of determining whether a formula is a tautology is fundamental in propositional logic. If there are ''n'' variables occurring in a formula then there are 2<sup>''n''</sup> distinct valuations for the formula. Therefore the task of determining whether or not the formula is a tautology is a finite, mechanical one: one need only evaluate the [[truth value]] of the formula under each of its possible valuations. One algorithmic method for verifying that every valuation causes this sentence to be true is to make a [[truth table]] that includes every possible valuation. | |||
For example, consider the formula | |||
:<math> ((A \land B) \to C) \Leftrightarrow (A \to (B \to C)).</math> | |||
There are 8 possible valuations for the propositional variables ''A'', ''B'', ''C'', represented by the first three columns of the following table. The remaining columns show the truth of subformulas of the formula above, culminating in a column showing the truth value of the original formula under each valuation. | |||
{| class="wikitable" style="text-align: center;" | |||
|- | |||
|A | |||
|B | |||
|C | |||
|<math>A \land B</math> | |||
|<math>(A \land B) \to C</math> | |||
|<math>B \to C</math> | |||
|<math>A \to (B \to C)</math> | |||
|<math>((A \land B) \to C) \Leftrightarrow (A \to (B \to C))</math> | |||
|- | |||
|T | |||
|T | |||
|T | |||
|T | |||
|T | |||
|T | |||
|T | |||
|T | |||
|- | |||
|T | |||
|T | |||
|F | |||
|T | |||
|F | |||
|F | |||
|F | |||
|T | |||
|- | |||
|T | |||
|F | |||
|T | |||
|F | |||
|T | |||
|T | |||
|T | |||
|T | |||
|- | |||
|T | |||
|F | |||
|F | |||
|F | |||
|T | |||
|T | |||
|T | |||
|T | |||
|- | |||
|F | |||
|T | |||
|T | |||
|F | |||
|T | |||
|T | |||
|T | |||
|T | |||
|- | |||
|F | |||
|T | |||
|F | |||
|F | |||
|T | |||
|F | |||
|T | |||
|T | |||
|- | |||
|F | |||
|F | |||
|T | |||
|F | |||
|T | |||
|T | |||
|T | |||
|T | |||
|- | |||
|F | |||
|F | |||
|F | |||
|F | |||
|T | |||
|T | |||
|T | |||
|T | |||
|} | |||
Because each row of the final column shows ''T'', the sentence in question is verified to be a tautology. | |||
It is also possible to define a [[deductive system]] (proof system) for propositional logic, as a simpler variant of the deductive systems employed for first-order logic (see Kleene 1957, Sec 1.9 for one such system). A proof of a tautology in an appropriate deduction system may be much shorter than a complete truth table (a formula with ''n'' propositional variables requires a truth table with 2<sup>''n''</sup> lines, which quickly becomes infeasible as ''n'' increases). Proof systems are also required for the study of intuitionistic propositional logic, in which the method of truth tables cannot be employed because the law of the excluded middle is not assumed. | |||
==Tautological implication== | |||
{{Main|Tautological consequence}} | |||
A formula ''R'' is said to '''tautologically imply''' a formula ''S'' if every valuation that causes ''R'' to be true also causes ''S'' to be true. This situation is denoted <math>R \models S</math>. It is equivalent to the formula <math>R \to S</math> being a tautology (Kleene 1967 p. 27). | |||
For example, let ''S'' be <math>A \land (B \lor \lnot B)</math>. Then ''S'' is not a tautology, because any valuation that makes ''A'' false will make ''S'' false. But any valuation that makes ''A'' true will make ''S'' true, because <math>B \lor \lnot B</math> is a tautology. Let ''R'' be the formula <math>A \land C</math>. Then <math>R \models S</math>, because any valuation satisfying ''R'' makes ''A'' true and thus makes ''S'' true. | |||
It follows from the definition that if a formula ''R'' is a contradiction then ''R'' tautologically implies every formula, because there is no truth valuation that causes ''R'' to be true and so the definition of tautological implication is trivially satisfied. Similarly, if ''S'' is a tautology then ''S'' is tautologically implied by every formula. | |||
==Substitution== | |||
{{Main|Substitution instance}} | |||
There is a general procedure, the '''substitution rule''', that allows additional tautologies to be | |||
constructed from a given tautology (Kleene 1967 sec. 3). Suppose that ''S'' is a tautology and for | |||
each propositional variable ''A'' in ''S'' a fixed sentence ''S''<sub>''A''</sub> is chosen. Then the | |||
sentence obtained by replacing each variable ''A'' in ''S'' with the corresponding sentence ''S''<sub>''A''</sub> is also a tautology. | |||
For example, let ''S'' be <math>(A \land B) \lor (\lnot A) \lor (\lnot B)</math>, a tautology. | |||
Let ''S''<sub>''A''</sub> be <math>C \lor D</math> and let ''S''<sub>''B''</sub> be <math>C \to E</math>. | |||
It follows from the substitution rule that the sentence | |||
:<math>((C \lor D) \land (C \to E)) \lor (\lnot (C \lor D) )\lor (\lnot (C \to E))</math> | |||
is a tautology. | |||
Efficient verification and the Boolean satisfiability problem | |||
The problem of constructing practical algorithms to determine whether sentences with large numbers of propositional variables are tautologies is an area of contemporary research in the area of [[automated theorem proving]]. | |||
The method of [[truth tables]] illustrated above is provably correct – the truth table for a tautology will end in a column with only ''T'', while the truth table for a sentence that is not a tautology will contain a row whose final column is ''F'', and the valuation corresponding to that row is a valuation that does not satisfy the sentence being tested. This method for verifying tautologies is an [[effective procedure]], which means that given unlimited computational resources it can always be used to mechanistically determine whether a sentence is a tautology. This means, in particular, the set of tautologies over a fixed finite or countable alphabet is a [[decidable set]]. | |||
As an [[efficient procedure]], however, truth tables are constrained by the fact that the number of valuations that must be checked increases as 2<sup>''k''</sup>, where ''k'' is the number of variables in the formula. This exponential growth in the computation length renders the truth table method useless for formulas with thousands of propositional variables, as contemporary computing hardware cannot execute the algorithm in a feasible time period. | |||
The problem of determining whether there is any valuation that makes a formula true is the '''[[Boolean satisfiability problem]]'''; the problem of checking tautologies is equivalent to this problem, because verifying that a sentence ''S'' is a tautology is equivalent to verifying that there is no valuation satisfying <math>\lnot S</math>. It is known that the Boolean satisfiability problem is [[NP complete]], and widely believed that there is no [[polynomial-time algorithm]] that can perform it. Current research focuses on finding algorithms that perform well on special classes of formulas, or terminate quickly on average even though some inputs may cause them to take much longer. | |||
==Tautologies versus validities in first-order logic== | |||
The fundamental definition of a tautology is in the context of propositional logic. The definition can be extended, however, to sentences in [[first-order logic]] (see Enderton (2002, p. 114) and Kleene (1967 secs. 17–18)). These sentences may contain quantifiers, unlike sentences of propositional logic. In the context of first-order logic, a distinction is maintained between '''logical validities''', sentences that are true in every model, and '''tautologies''', which are a proper subset of the first-order logical validities. In the context of propositional logic, these two terms coincide. | |||
A tautology in first-order logic is a sentence that can be obtained by taking a tautology of propositional logic and uniformly replacing each propositional variable by a first-order formula (one formula per propositional variable). For example, | |||
because <math>A \lor \lnot A</math> is a tautology of propositional logic, <math> (\forall x ( x = x)) \lor (\lnot \forall x (x = x))</math> is a tautology in first order logic. Similarly, in a first-order language with a unary relation symbols ''R'',''S'',''T'', the following sentence is a tautology: | |||
:<math>(((\exists x Rx) \land \lnot (\exists x Sx)) \to \forall x Tx) \Leftrightarrow ((\exists x Rx) \to ((\lnot \exists x Sx) \to \forall x Tx)).</math> | |||
It is obtained by replacing <math>A</math> with <math>\exists x Rx</math>, <math>B</math> with <math>\lnot \exists x Sx</math>, and <math>C</math> with <math>\forall x Tx</math> in the propositional tautology <math>((A \land B) \to C) \Leftrightarrow (A \to (B \to C))</math>. | |||
Not all logical validities are tautologies in first-order logic. For example, the sentence | |||
:<math>(\forall x Rx) \to \lnot \exists x \lnot Rx</math> | |||
is true in any first-order interpretation, but it corresponds to the propositional sentence <math>A \to B</math> which is not a tautology of propositional logic. | |||
==See also== | |||
===Normal forms=== | |||
* [[Algebraic normal form]] | |||
* [[Conjunctive normal form]] | |||
* [[Disjunctive normal form]] | |||
* [[Logic optimization]] | |||
===Related logical topics=== | |||
{{col-begin}} | |||
{{col-break}} | |||
* [[Boolean algebra]] | |||
* [[Boolean domain]] | |||
* [[Boolean function]] | |||
* [[List of logic symbols]] | |||
{{col-break}} | |||
* [[Logic synthesis]] | |||
* [[Logical consequence]] | |||
* [[Logical graph]] | |||
* [[Vacuous truth]] | |||
{{col-end}} | |||
==References== | |||
*[[Józef Maria Bocheński|Bocheński, J. M.]] (1959) ''Précis of Mathematical Logic'', translated from the French and German editions by Otto Bird, [[Dordrecht]], [[South Holland]]: [[D. Reidel]]. | |||
*[[Herbert Enderton|Enderton, H. B.]] (2002) ''A Mathematical Introduction to Logic'', [[Harcourt (publisher)|Harcourt]]/[[Academic Press]], ISBN 0-12-238452-0. | |||
*[[Stephen Kleene|Kleene, S. C.]] (1967) ''Mathematical Logic'', reprinted 2002, [[Dover Publications]], ISBN 0-486-42533-9. | |||
*[[Hans Reichenbach|Reichenbach, H.]] (1947). ''Elements of Symbolic Logic'', reprinted 1980, Dover, ISBN 0-486-24004-5 | |||
*[[Ludwig Wittgenstein|Wittgenstein, L.]] (1921). "Logisch-philosophiche Abhandlung", ''Annalen der Naturphilosophie'' (Leipzig), v. 14, pp. 185–262, reprinted in English translation as ''Tractatus logico-philosophicus'', [[New York]] and [[London]], 1922. | |||
==External links== | |||
* {{springer|title=Tautology|id=p/t092290}} | |||
* {{Mathworld|title=Tautology|urlname=Tautology}} | |||
{{Logical connectives}} | |||
{{Logic}} | |||
{{DEFAULTSORT:Tautology (Logic)}} | |||
[[Category:Logical expressions]] | |||
[[Category:Logical truth]] | |||
[[Category:Mathematical logic]] | |||
[[Category:Propositional calculus]] | |||
[[Category:Propositions]] | |||
[[Category:Semantics]] | |||
[[Category:Sentences by type]] |
Revision as of 20:04, 29 December 2013
In logic, a tautology (from the Greek word ταυτολογία) is a formula which is true in every possible interpretation. Philosopher Ludwig Wittgenstein first applied the term to redundancies of propositional logic in 1921; (it had been used earlier to refer to rhetorical tautologies, and continues to be used in that alternate sense). A formula is satisfiable if it is true under at least one interpretation, and thus a tautology is a formula whose negation is unsatisfiable. Unsatisfiable statements, both through negation and affirmation, are known formally as contradictions. A formula that is neither a tautology nor a contradiction is said to be logically contingent. Such a formula can be made either true or false based on the values assigned to its propositional variables. The double turnstile notation is used to indicate that S is a tautology. Tautology is sometimes symbolized by "Vpq", and contradiction by "Opq". The tee symbol is sometimes used to denote an arbitrary tautology, with the dual symbol (falsum) representing an arbitrary contradiction.
Tautologies are a key concept in propositional logic, where a tautology is defined as a propositional formula that is true under any possible Boolean valuation of its propositional variables. A key property of tautologies in propositional logic is that an effective method exists for testing whether a given formula is always satisfied (or, equivalently, whether its negation is unsatisfiable).
The definition of tautology can be extended to sentences in predicate logic, which may contain quantifiers, unlike sentences of propositional logic. In propositional logic, there is no distinction between a tautology and a logically valid formula. In the context of predicate logic, many authors define a tautology to be a sentence that can be obtained by taking a tautology of propositional logic and uniformly replacing each propositional variable by a first-order formula (one formula per propositional variable). The set of such formulas is a proper subset of the set of logically valid sentences of predicate logic (which are the sentences that are true in every model).
History
The word tautology was used by the ancient Greeks to describe a statement that was true merely by virtue of saying the same thing twice, a pejorative meaning that is still used for rhetorical tautologies. Between 1800 and 1940, the word gained new meaning in logic, and is currently used in mathematical logic to denote a certain type of propositional formula, without the pejorative connotations it originally possessed.
In 1800, Immanuel Kant wrote in his book Logic:
- "The identity of concepts in analytical judgments can be either explicit (explicita) or non-explicit (implicita). In the former case analytic propositions are tautological."
Here analytic proposition refers to an analytic truth, a statement in natural language that is true solely because of the terms involved.
In 1884, Gottlob Frege proposed in his Grundlagen that a truth is analytic exactly if it can be derived using logic. But he maintained a distinction between analytic truths (those true based only on the meanings of their terms) and tautologies (statements devoid of content).
In 1921, in his Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus, Ludwig Wittgenstein proposed that statements that can be deduced by logical deduction are tautological (empty of meaning) as well as being analytic truths. Henri Poincaré had made similar remarks in Science and Hypothesis in 1905. Although Bertrand Russell at first argued against these remarks by Wittgenstein and Poincaré, claiming that mathematical truths were not only non-tautologous but were synthetic, he later spoke in favor of them in 1918:
- "Everything that is a proposition of logic has got to be in some sense or the other like a tautology. It has got to be something that has some peculiar quality, which I do not know how to define, that belongs to logical propositions but not to others."
Here logical proposition refers to a proposition that is provable using the laws of logic.
During the 1930s, the formalization of the semantics of propositional logic in terms of truth assignments was developed. The term tautology began to be applied to those propositional formulas that are true regardless of the truth or falsity of their propositional variables. Some early books on logic (such as Symbolic Logic by C. I. Lewis and Langford, 1932) used the term for any proposition (in any formal logic) that is universally valid. It is common in presentations after this (such as Stephen Kleene 1967 and Herbert Enderton 2002) to use tautology to refer to a logically valid propositional formula, but to maintain a distinction between tautology and logically valid in the context of first-order logic (see below).
Background
Mining Engineer (Excluding Oil ) Truman from Alma, loves to spend time knotting, largest property developers in singapore developers in singapore and stamp collecting. Recently had a family visit to Urnes Stave Church.
Propositional logic begins with propositional variables, atomic units that represent concrete propositions. A formula consists of propositional variables connected by logical connectives in a meaningful way, so that the truth of the overall formula can be uniquely deduced from the truth or falsity of each variable. A valuation is a function that assigns each propositional variable either T (for truth) or F (for falsity). So, for example, using the propositional variables A and B, the binary connectives and representing disjunction and conjunction respectively, and the unary connective representing negation, the following formula can be obtained::. A valuation here must assign to each of A and B either T or F. But no matter how this assignment is made, the overall formula will come out true. For if the first conjunction is not satisfied by a particular valuation, then one of A and B is assigned F, which will cause the corresponding later disjunct to be T.
Definition and examples
A formula of propositional logic is a tautology if the formula itself is always true regardless of which valuation is used for the propositional variables.
There are infinitely many tautologies. Examples include:
- ("A or not A"), the law of the excluded middle. This formula has only one propositional variable, A. Any valuation for this formula must, by definition, assign A one of the truth values true or false, and assign A the other truth value.
- ("if A implies B then not-B implies not-A", and vice versa), which expresses the law of contraposition.
- ("if not-A implies both B and its negation not-B, then not-A must be false, then A must be true"), which is the principle known as reductio ad absurdum.
- ("if not both A and B, then either not-A or not-B", and vice versa), which is known as de Morgan's law.
- ("if A implies B and B implies C, then A implies C"), which is the principle known as syllogism.
- (if at least one of A or B is true, and each implies C, then C must be true as well), which is the principle known as proof by cases.
A minimal tautology is a tautology that is not the instance of a shorter tautology.
Verifying tautologies
The problem of determining whether a formula is a tautology is fundamental in propositional logic. If there are n variables occurring in a formula then there are 2n distinct valuations for the formula. Therefore the task of determining whether or not the formula is a tautology is a finite, mechanical one: one need only evaluate the truth value of the formula under each of its possible valuations. One algorithmic method for verifying that every valuation causes this sentence to be true is to make a truth table that includes every possible valuation.
For example, consider the formula
There are 8 possible valuations for the propositional variables A, B, C, represented by the first three columns of the following table. The remaining columns show the truth of subformulas of the formula above, culminating in a column showing the truth value of the original formula under each valuation.
A | B | C | |||||
T | T | T | T | T | T | T | T |
T | T | F | T | F | F | F | T |
T | F | T | F | T | T | T | T |
T | F | F | F | T | T | T | T |
F | T | T | F | T | T | T | T |
F | T | F | F | T | F | T | T |
F | F | T | F | T | T | T | T |
F | F | F | F | T | T | T | T |
Because each row of the final column shows T, the sentence in question is verified to be a tautology.
It is also possible to define a deductive system (proof system) for propositional logic, as a simpler variant of the deductive systems employed for first-order logic (see Kleene 1957, Sec 1.9 for one such system). A proof of a tautology in an appropriate deduction system may be much shorter than a complete truth table (a formula with n propositional variables requires a truth table with 2n lines, which quickly becomes infeasible as n increases). Proof systems are also required for the study of intuitionistic propositional logic, in which the method of truth tables cannot be employed because the law of the excluded middle is not assumed.
Tautological implication
Mining Engineer (Excluding Oil ) Truman from Alma, loves to spend time knotting, largest property developers in singapore developers in singapore and stamp collecting. Recently had a family visit to Urnes Stave Church.
A formula R is said to tautologically imply a formula S if every valuation that causes R to be true also causes S to be true. This situation is denoted . It is equivalent to the formula being a tautology (Kleene 1967 p. 27).
For example, let S be . Then S is not a tautology, because any valuation that makes A false will make S false. But any valuation that makes A true will make S true, because is a tautology. Let R be the formula . Then , because any valuation satisfying R makes A true and thus makes S true.
It follows from the definition that if a formula R is a contradiction then R tautologically implies every formula, because there is no truth valuation that causes R to be true and so the definition of tautological implication is trivially satisfied. Similarly, if S is a tautology then S is tautologically implied by every formula.
Substitution
Mining Engineer (Excluding Oil ) Truman from Alma, loves to spend time knotting, largest property developers in singapore developers in singapore and stamp collecting. Recently had a family visit to Urnes Stave Church.
There is a general procedure, the substitution rule, that allows additional tautologies to be constructed from a given tautology (Kleene 1967 sec. 3). Suppose that S is a tautology and for each propositional variable A in S a fixed sentence SA is chosen. Then the sentence obtained by replacing each variable A in S with the corresponding sentence SA is also a tautology.
For example, let S be , a tautology. Let SA be and let SB be . It follows from the substitution rule that the sentence
is a tautology.
Efficient verification and the Boolean satisfiability problem The problem of constructing practical algorithms to determine whether sentences with large numbers of propositional variables are tautologies is an area of contemporary research in the area of automated theorem proving.
The method of truth tables illustrated above is provably correct – the truth table for a tautology will end in a column with only T, while the truth table for a sentence that is not a tautology will contain a row whose final column is F, and the valuation corresponding to that row is a valuation that does not satisfy the sentence being tested. This method for verifying tautologies is an effective procedure, which means that given unlimited computational resources it can always be used to mechanistically determine whether a sentence is a tautology. This means, in particular, the set of tautologies over a fixed finite or countable alphabet is a decidable set.
As an efficient procedure, however, truth tables are constrained by the fact that the number of valuations that must be checked increases as 2k, where k is the number of variables in the formula. This exponential growth in the computation length renders the truth table method useless for formulas with thousands of propositional variables, as contemporary computing hardware cannot execute the algorithm in a feasible time period.
The problem of determining whether there is any valuation that makes a formula true is the Boolean satisfiability problem; the problem of checking tautologies is equivalent to this problem, because verifying that a sentence S is a tautology is equivalent to verifying that there is no valuation satisfying . It is known that the Boolean satisfiability problem is NP complete, and widely believed that there is no polynomial-time algorithm that can perform it. Current research focuses on finding algorithms that perform well on special classes of formulas, or terminate quickly on average even though some inputs may cause them to take much longer.
Tautologies versus validities in first-order logic
The fundamental definition of a tautology is in the context of propositional logic. The definition can be extended, however, to sentences in first-order logic (see Enderton (2002, p. 114) and Kleene (1967 secs. 17–18)). These sentences may contain quantifiers, unlike sentences of propositional logic. In the context of first-order logic, a distinction is maintained between logical validities, sentences that are true in every model, and tautologies, which are a proper subset of the first-order logical validities. In the context of propositional logic, these two terms coincide.
A tautology in first-order logic is a sentence that can be obtained by taking a tautology of propositional logic and uniformly replacing each propositional variable by a first-order formula (one formula per propositional variable). For example, because is a tautology of propositional logic, is a tautology in first order logic. Similarly, in a first-order language with a unary relation symbols R,S,T, the following sentence is a tautology:
It is obtained by replacing with , with , and with in the propositional tautology .
Not all logical validities are tautologies in first-order logic. For example, the sentence
is true in any first-order interpretation, but it corresponds to the propositional sentence which is not a tautology of propositional logic.
See also
Normal forms
Related logical topics
Template:Col-begin Template:Col-break
References
- Bocheński, J. M. (1959) Précis of Mathematical Logic, translated from the French and German editions by Otto Bird, Dordrecht, South Holland: D. Reidel.
- Enderton, H. B. (2002) A Mathematical Introduction to Logic, Harcourt/Academic Press, ISBN 0-12-238452-0.
- Kleene, S. C. (1967) Mathematical Logic, reprinted 2002, Dover Publications, ISBN 0-486-42533-9.
- Reichenbach, H. (1947). Elements of Symbolic Logic, reprinted 1980, Dover, ISBN 0-486-24004-5
- Wittgenstein, L. (1921). "Logisch-philosophiche Abhandlung", Annalen der Naturphilosophie (Leipzig), v. 14, pp. 185–262, reprinted in English translation as Tractatus logico-philosophicus, New York and London, 1922.
External links
- Other Sports Official Kull from Drumheller, has hobbies such as telescopes, property developers in singapore and crocheting. Identified some interesting places having spent 4 months at Saloum Delta.
my web-site http://himerka.com/ - 22 year-old Systems Analyst Rave from Merrickville-Wolford, has lots of hobbies and interests including quick cars, property developers in singapore and baking. Always loves visiting spots like Historic Monuments Zone of Querétaro.
Here is my web site - cottagehillchurch.com
Tn Requin Pas Cher diamond trading
Ahead of when modifications in regulatings having banned from the game manage behind options Tn Requin Pas Cher alongside ephedra, 2 day diet outlet Up to now the idea Longchamp Soldes gel that the majority of made this encourage of one obtained in many food lifestyle prescription medication..
Sure, I can remove any of these fairly easy, but it should be a quick reminder to keep me on track. Promo code expires on date stated and can be withdrawn without notice.. :( No parent should ever be praised for their detachment from their children, especially while the child cries alone...
As it turned out, I really had a lot of fun, even though it was hard work. If they believe that RAW is doing good then I believe ISI doing the same thing and also the FBI, CIA, NSA, KGB, MI , MOSSAD and others.. The Foundation purchased 102 paintings from Miss Lassie Stylo Mont Blanc Pas Cher for $275,000, plus $10,000 for all incidents of absolute ownership.
The newest untethered(read more). Melvin G. Wan, director of the public affairs' doctoral program and associate dean for research for the college. It had more than 650 million registered accounts by December 2011. And we're interrupted, on average, once every 10.5 minutes by instant messages, Facebook messages and tweets.
Cyn is also the Slayer of Red Tape Dragons, THE Mommy, and She Who Says What Must Be Said (especially when people don't Ralph Lauren Home want, but need, to hearit)... These awards has given the group huge exposure and the opportunity to begin work on a second album.Michael Harrison, on fiddle, creates a distinctive sound using original and colourful techniques..
If you actually want to attract women and begin to end up like money in the bank then you to know one easy little concept. In modern English a casino can you get high off of oxycodone apapould you get high off of oxycodone aa facility entertainment events such as.
They are a full service refinery that does bullion trading, diamond trading, stone removal, and much more read more Quality Inn Savage 20 views8/02/2013, Book you stay today! read more Torchlight Productions: Delivering integrated internet based options 23 views8/02/2013 .
The figure 5A, shows the accumulation in tumor to a certain extent and maximum amount of complex was accumulated in the RES (particularly liver and spleen) after 24 h of injection of 99mTcML.. The funny thing about the pics on the World Red Eye site Nike Free 3.0 is that they also give you the name of the person.
You can, however, run a search from inside the widget, which is a nice touch.. There's quite a few people buying up the current Mac Pro now because they are unsure of what the next revision will bring. The update is now available as a 15MB update on Dell's site...
- http://sundae.se/2004/01/28/b2evolution/
- http://myextremeauto.com/activity/p/183272/
- http://passerelle.ethiopie.free.fr/spip.php?article448/
- http://blog.myoeoe.com.tw/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=2553453
Adidas Wings rire
Quand il a payé le prêt, mon BF a décidé de l'utiliser pour ma bague. Adidas Wings Directives pas disponible. Comment faire de l'argent rapidement à 12 ans Besoin d'un peu d'argent supplémentaire à Jeremy Scott Pas Cher la hâte? mais vous devez peser au moins 110 livres, soit entre les âges de 18 et 59how faire comment faire de l'argent rapidement à l'âge de 12 l'argent rapidement à 13 ans? à 12 ans j'ai fauché pelouses et lavé les voitures que j'avais environ 20 clients réguliers et fait environ Abercrombie Soldes 320 par semaine.
Elle va comme ça. Mais jusqu'à ce que vous pouvez venir à cet accord, vous ne savez pas à coup sûr. Travaux dans tous les autres corridors sont snailpaced. Chanel Lunettes Le record de John McCain de travailler avec les démocrates dépasse facilement. Si vous flirté avec quelqu'un, choisi votre nez, acheté un magazine fétiche, ou dit à quelqu'un que vous les aimiez, vos voisins se regarder, rire, et de discuter comme si c'était juste une autre émission de télé réalité.
Ses parents ont déménagé ici quand il était encore un enfant. Les temps de réponse des ambulances sont au plus bas. Pour moi et pour eux. [HendersonCyber fille et modèle Editions spéciales Mariela Henderson fait enfin ses débuts sur le réseau Playboy filles comme une femme au foyer chaude récemment marié! Les fans de temps long de Mariela reconnaîtront les charmes ludiques et délicieuses courbes qui la rendaient si populaire.
Une élection de chaussette comme cochon et fichier local comme chantent été oublié jusqu'à réparation depuis tortellini à côté des politiques d'intérêt national. Une série de huit barrages sucer l'eau du Colorado comme il se déplace vers le sud vers le Mexique.
Vous n'avez pas interagir avec eux, sauf si cela est absolument nécessaire, et quand vous le faites, vous le garder à un minimum absolu. Maintenant, si vous êtes un de ceux ou 2 sites seulement des marketeurs internet (lol) alors ce logiciel est probablement pas pour vous, il suffit de payer un service de répertoire de 50 dollars et vous verrez environ 10 liens dans le cadre de plus d'un an.
Enfants es peuvent être issus de familles traditionnellement religieuses ou de familles comme celle du président Barack Obama, dont la mère était une humaniste laïque. Là, un énorme 87 pour cent de tous les utilisateurs sont en cours d'exécution des applications iPhone une nette avance qui donne Android et Nike Cortez Vintage JavaME seulement 6 pour cent et 7 pour cent, respectivement, de ce qui reste.
Il aide vraiment notre caucus et il est amusant. 7482085 Téléchargez votre moteur en marche: les propriétaires de voitures classiques easyontheeye sont invités à examiner présentant à l'Hospice de Concours d'Elégance du comté de SLO prévue pour Juin 123 dans les prés au Madonna Inn.
- http://www.mariettakaramanli.fr/spip.php?article647/
- http://www.importia.com/index.php/forum/newtopic
- http://aslm.org/aslm2012/index.php?option=com_kunena&func=view&catid=5&id=60113&Itemid=615#60113
- http://www.mistachasezodiacs.com/index.php?option=com_kunena&func=view&catid=6&id=298324&Itemid=53#298324
Polo Ralph Lauren Femme "Weather Sky."
THE GRAY CHEVY AVALANCHE RAISED A RED FLAG FOR THE PAPER. 4) and Iowa State (Jan. Sphyllis vesicular. Ed Sheeran] Taylor Swift Reignfall Chamillionaire My Story (feat. The only legal way to access any web site with a crawler was to obtain prior written permission.
The post, titled "Luka Magnotta : Multiculturalism is Dangerous," includes a manifesto purportedly written by him. In. Footage from the construction of Dadara s Fool s Ark at Burning Man is intertwined into an audio visual journey through forgotten worlds to tell the story of the project.
Police seek help with highprofile cold case, 'Matilda the Musical' says goodbye to 2 stars, Actor Dwayne Johnson leaves wrestling career open, Most Popular, Advertise With Us, Our Company, Editions Apps, Follow mySA.. But if the United States wasn't prepared to scrap its maddeningly difficult relationship with Russia because of missile defense, human rights or Syria's civil Polo Ralph Lauren Femme war, it's unlikely the 30yearold National Security Agency leaker alone will sour ties irrevocably between two powers that both have moved past their halfcentury Cold War for global supremacy..
Pasteurized milk gives my Nike Cortez Vintage daughter chronic diarrhea of which prevents her from absorbing nutrients and keeps her from gaining weight. The hotel provides a complimentary minibus to Dunkeld and Birnam Golf Course.. One developer, a selfdescribed "visionary for puzzles" who looked like a skateboarderrecentlyturneddad, displayed a jackedup, interactive game called Puzzingo, intended for Nike Air Force Pas Cher toddlers and .
Still in that January simplifyingyourlife mode? C'mon, man, these are books: you can never have too many. For about a week now I have been suffering from a intermittent loss of connection to the internet the internet will be fine until it randomly decides to drop out.
Bing Ads Editor More Webinar: Boost Louis Vuitton Evidence Pas Cher Your Search ROI with Bing Ads EditorConsumer Electronics are at the Top of the List for BacktoSchool Jul 26, 2013 6: . Picture: Roger Wyman H0406720 Readers come out in favour of cafe vision GLENELG TIM WILLIAMS HOLDFAST Bay Mayor Ken Rollond's idea for a threestorey restaurant complex on the site of the former Scampi's restaurant has .
Jonathan L. The results are surprisingly dynamic and musical, as can be heard on the recordings released of his solo works and in the company of Rowe, Sachiko M, Jason Kahn, and Andrea Neumann, to name but a few." The two are Gucci Chaussure out in support of an album, "Weather Sky." (TC)..
Our visitors had starting posting their valuable comments and encouraged us and finally in April 2012 we beenmigrated. What is the usage intended for hexomedine cream? 0. (what it will do is help with load times and memory speed due to the page file and random access times)Re: Graphic Cards and stuffPost by kokusho on Apr 21, 2010, 4:33amUsually I don't often clear my Firefox cache, and moreover, I have a Smart Defrag running most of the time, which autodefrags files quite a lot.
- http://star1034.egloos.com/2230281/
- http://verdamilio.net/tonio/spip.php?article1970/
- http://verdamilio.net/tonio/spip.php?article1536/
- http://www.kjfxw.com/home.php?mod=spacecp&ac=blog&blogid=
Nike Air Max 90 Pas Cher il perd 2 points. Elle se penche
trent's reported and produced stories from turkey to rural alabama
Alessandra revient de The Wall Street Journal, où elle a passé 12 ans à Londres, Paris, Milan et Rome. De Wikipedia, l'encyclopédie libre. Cependant, Nike Air Max 90 Pas Cher comme le gouvernement crie d'une épidémie jeu de dépendance à Internet, les études montrent qu'aucune hausse importante dépendance au Oakley Frogskins jeu existe..
Les principes fondamentaux de la gestion de l'argent, des stratégies pour économiser de l'argent, et la façon de planifier pour l'avenir. Maintenant dis, encore et encore, "Je ne suis pas une carte de travail, je ne suis pas un job board" Oui, vous savez comme moi que l'emploi LinkedInisa Hermes Ceinture bord.
Sauf si vous son médecin ou un médecin pour cette question, je ne pense que vous devez vous préoccuper de son poids. Je pense simplement que nous pouvons faire mieux, Sanger said.are un certain nombre de problèmes avec le système qui peuvent être résolus, et en résolvant ceux que nous pouvons retrouver avec une encyclopédie encore mieux massif, il added.An la version inviteonly pilote du but non lucratif le site va lancer cette semaine, bien qu'il y ait pas de nouvelles au sujet d'un lieu release.The plein de WikipediaIn cinq courtes années, le advertfree Wikipedia est devenu l'un des outils de recherche les plus populaires sur le Web, avec plus de 2 millions d'articles dans 229 nationalités, avec Nielsen NetRatings enregistre plus de 33 millions de visiteurs uniques en Septembre de cette year.Such est la croissance explosive du site, ce chiffre représente un énorme 162 pour cent augmentation de la période correspondante year.With toute personne capable d'écrire et de modifier du contenu sur Wikipedia, l' site a été accusé de manque Louis Vuitton Chaussures de fiabilité, avec des sujets controversés et des entrées politiques crouler sous interminable conflits de belligérants factions.Larry Sanger espère introduire un peu d'ordre à son site rival en introduisant des éditeurs, des bénévoles et la responsabilité personnelle qui verront les gens en utilisant des noms réels .
Par exemple, si une équipe ordonne à quatre et ne fait que huit Nike Shox tours au lieu des 10 requis, il perd 2 points. Elle se penche, et un étalon black commence à mousser. Assurez-vous que la compagnie que vous choisissez est financièrement solide. Tout ce riche contenu du profil de médias est tirée d'une longue liste de sources pertinentes régionales et internationales ainsi que, tout pour vous permettre de trouver des gens en temps réel.
Ezekiel atteint dans l'histoire américaine 20 ème siècle pour ce qu'il croit être l'analogie la plus proche. Il y avait beaucoup de chiffre d'affaires l'an dernier. Si vous songez à une entreprise sur Internet, il doit y avoir un produit qui a une énorme demande et qui peuvent être vendus sur Internet.
- http://51qiuyuan.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=725428&fromuid=150357
- http://general.assembly.codesria.org/spip.php?article87&lang=pt/
- http://kanghaozhongguo.com/news/html/?115632.html
- http://enseignement-lsf.com/spip.php?article64#forum24511898
Nike Blazer Femme bunkers
In fact he spends a bit of time in the book to talk about Mike Schmidt and how unloved he was by the Philly fans even though he was such a great player. Writing large buggy programs is hard. Anyway, Michael Carbonaro is a comics lifer and a pal, and we wish him the best with his new venture, Carbo Comic Box, whatever it is.
There is another battsman at the other end of the wicket (the 20 yards). Many of the SSDs that we review have excellent performance and pricing, yet these lack the tools that make having an SSD easy Nike Blazer Femme and enjoyable. Spirit has shown itself to be so impoverished that it seems to yearn for its refreshment merely in the meager feeling of Louis Vuitton Chaussures divinity, very much like the wanderer in the desert who longs for a Ray Ban New Wayfarer simple drink of water.
And with keeping in mind that these are the midrange cards, I just get the impression that this was done to force Nvidia to drop their prices. The Occupational Health Adviser is available Lunettes De Soleil Chanel to provide ALL employees with confidential advice and support on any health issues.
The 4.2 mile course winds through the streets of Tempe and both events are staged so that all participants finish on the 42yard line on Frank Kush Field inside Sun Devil Stadium, symbolic of the 42 jersey that Pat wore while he was a Sun Devil. My Clarkdale i3530 with 3.5" WD10EADS also uses 30W idle.
All efforts were made to arrange the function as per tradition and it was quite a successful meet. What is the usage intended for hexomedine cream? 0. .. I had received numerous emails about PLR articles and had no idea how they could benefit me until I attended a Teleseminar on the topic and was amazed at the benefits of using PLR products.
SAP solutions for small businesses and midsize companies include SAP Business One, a single integrated, application for successfully managing small businesses; SAP Business ByDesign, the software industry's most complete, integrated and adaptable ondemand solution for midsize companies , available in a controlled rampup process to prospects in six focus countries; and SAP Business AllinOne, a customizable and extensible solution for midsize companies with deep builtin industry best practices..
In 2009, Bob was declared NED (no evidence of disease) and today has passed the remarkable milestone of being a 5 year survivor.. I counted more than 600 instructional videos organized into sections Adidas Jeremy Scott Pas Cher for various parts of the game (putting, irons and hybrids, bunkers) and a huge section on fundamentals..
- http://www.ovnprod.com/spip.php?article24/
- http://general.assembly.codesria.org/spip.php?article87&lang=pt/
- http://bbs.huanqiu.com/forum.php?mod=forumdisplay&fid=114&filter=typeid&typeid=180&mod=spacecp&ac=blog&blogid=
- http://www.stmarychurchportland.org/katAK
Gucci Chaussures
Bon journalisme exige équilibre, cet article est totalement biaisée, juste pour avoir une balançoire à EDS. Pour quelle fin je me demande. Il n'est pas Gucci Chaussures fait mention de tous les projets gouvernementaux EDS ont livré avec succès par exemple pour le fisc de 10 ans, ou non gouvernement pour GM à Luton pour plus longtemps que cela.
La nuit dernière, j'ai essayé de retourner un vélo à la gare sur la rue Pitt (je dockblocked à la station la plus proche de chez vous!). La lumière jaune a continué, et est resté, le vélo a été enfermé dans le dock. Je suis allé au kiosque d'obtenir un reçu.
Une des premières choses que je suggère un joueur essai est la suivante: Allez sur un putting green et putt quelques courtes avec différents clubs. Essayez la pointe d'un coin de sable, essayez un pilote, essayez un fer 2 ou un hybride. La plupart des Christian Louboutin Femme joueurs sont Oakley Holbrook surpris par la façon dont ils peuvent putt utilisation de ces clubs.
La bonne sélection et la hiérarchisation des projets est l'un des facteurs critiques de succès d'un programme Six Sigma. La priorisation des projets dans de nombreuses organisations est toujours basé sur un jugement subjectif pur. Très peu d'outils puissants sont disponibles pour la priorisation des projets, ce qui devrait être des grands axes de la recherche dans l'avenir..
Il n'est jamais une chose facile pour tenter d'identifier une créature marine de cinq pour cent de leur corps qui dépasse au-dessus de l'eau. Malheureusement, la récente paranoïa Nouvelle-Angleterre sur les grands requins blancs couplés avec une longue tradition de la suite du film a créé une tempête de folie et faux requins observations. Comme avec toutes les choses, il est utile de mettre ce que vous voyez dans la nature dans son Ceinture Gucci contexte.
Quand quelqu'un s'approche de vous et vous dit: «Bonjour, comment vas-tu?" votre cerveau reçoit une entrée audio de vos oreilles sous la forme de la langue anglaise. Vibram France Cette entrée est alors «analysée» par le cortex cérébral dans un endroit appelé «zone de Wernicke". Cette section du cerveau prend l'information audio et il se décompose sur la base de l'inflexion, la syntaxe, et d'autres facteurs.
Collins a un jumeau identique, Jaron, qui était «stupéfait» de découvrir que son frère était entré dans le mode de vie homosexuel. Lui, malgré le partage ADN identique de Jason, est droit comme un faisceau laser. Les jumeaux identiques partagent détroits [! Sic] qui sont génétiquement déterminé: la taille, la couleur de peau, couleur des yeux, couleur des cheveux et ainsi de suite.
- http://www.middleeasttransparent.com/spip.php?article9467&lang=ar&id_forum=10581/
- http://ldsbee.com/index.php?page=item&id=4271394
- http://www.metransparent.com/spip.php?article9653&lang=ar&id_forum=11085/
- http://theroot66garden.org/index.php/forum/welcome-mat/130749-polo-ralph-lauren-femme-pas-cher-doityourself-eyetesting-that-the-consumer-could-administer#133029
Oakley France Tori Pappalardo
It is quite simply an amazing story of life and mankind. The tropics spread to the Arctic and Wyoming saw some curious creatures flourish: horses, rodents and pintsized primates, the precursors to men, monkeys and apes long ago... Keep that in mind the next Oakley France time you are driving 207 mph.
Issue 8. His nine grandchildren, Brad Bitler, Nicole, Austin Pappalardo, Casey, Alli, Tori Pappalardo, Anthony, Elizabeth Pappalardo.. The Independent Pilots seriously injured in Von Valley crash Voxy Italy supreme court upholds Berlusconi jail sentence Reuters Prime Minister Kevin Rudd plans to pinch Aussies' savings to plug budget black ..
The water to them is just something to make money off of.. Using our proprietary search algorithm, you can find comprehensive and centralized person related information consisting of public records, phone numbers, addresses, images, videos and email addresses.
WowJust a fantastic site, and my most read rss feed by far. Get yourself a pair of bombproof nylon pants (they won't rip). The idea that you were baited in to hunt "big mean wild Texas hogs" and then giving up on that you pay them more money to shoot one of their more expensive animals.
Louis area. Read the article to find out more.. You must also look at your retorts such as expressions or perhaps hurling angry words at him. Coaches need to remind their players that all the heavy conditioning will be lifelong examples the players can use when basketball becomes just a fond memory..
This review is for a book that is several "cuts above" the others I've been posting. Completely there exists a lot more risks Louis Vuitton Chaussure in terms of have too heavy regarding body instead of possessing bloodstream which can be way too slender.. [. Lewis"The Revolutioniz package really is everything it claims to be the most comprehensive and detailed 'system' Prada Chaussure around for getting the Law of Attraction to work for ordinary people especially anyone (like me) who has already absorbed the basics but has been floundering around not really knowing clearly how to apply the information." Lisa Cannington"What separates this resource .
He hates libtards, a real plus. A photography (good resolution) for free for the one that can help me out!!Thanks. Polo Ralph Lauren Femme Pas Cher You can also keep yourself up to date with the latest downloads in the site, view what other people are downloading at that time and you can also catch the latest on what is happening in the world with the Download Youtuber News...
If you're in the bathtub, you don't Nike Jordan Pas Cher want to have your laptop sitting on your chest," he said. Sometimes while I am benching, I do sets of standing calf raises. The company has posted they are always looking for new parts to upcycle and takes donations through their site.
- http://xzzbg.com/news/html/?785233.html
- http://www.philatelie-france-russie.fr/spip.php?article51/
- http://verdamilio.info/org/spip.php?article573/
- http://www.observatoiredesreligions.fr/spip.php?article9
Beats Pill Pas Cher qui n'a pas vraiment été exploré
Louis aurait probablement Beats Pill Pas Cher été un cruiserweight par Ralph Lauren Pas Cher des normes d'aujourd'hui il n'est que juste que il se classe au-dessus de certains des plus grands puncheurs poids lourd en termes de puissance livre pour livre. Offres d'emploi en raison des paroles d'amour d'amour d'amour.
Elle a gagné 5 médailles pour son service exceptionnel, et a été le premier coureur femelle de la première Afghanistan Marathon, soit un total de 12 marathons elle a terminé avec gagner le prix de remise en forme le plus élevé au cours de la formation de base de l'armée..
Il Fred Perry France pourrait y avoir une énorme protestation qui pourrait causer la vie des gens, il pourrait y avoir une autre attaque sur le sol américain (et pour mémoire, je ne suis pas un terroriste!), Il pourrait y avoir une attaque dans l'un des alliés des Etats-Etat, le possibilités sont infinies qui pourraient nous amener à une révolution plus spirituel et nous faire devenir plus spirituel..
C'est tout évident, suffisamment explicites, et selffinding. En fait, le seul passage qui permettait la circulation entre les deux la plaine et les basses terres côtières et les montagnes de Samarie était une bande de terre entre deux kilomètres Migdal Afek et les sources du Yarkon.
Elle est curable, pas de soucis bronchite est une inflammation des bronches ou des poumons. Minecraft est un jeu vidéo Nike Air Force 1 Femme à composition non limitée qui permet aux joueurs de construire des maisons et des communautés virtuelles avec quelques frappes simples.
Les moteurs de recherche indexent votre contenu sur leurs nouveaux sites dans les deux ou trois jours. Dave a fait remarquer que vous n savez vraiment ce que vous ouvrez quelqu'un pour si vous avez beaucoup de disciples et vous les retweet. Il va changer beaucoup de règles sur la conduite et la couverture d'assurance.
Une merveille de la nature. OBLIGATIONS: Certains investisseurs et les commerçants ont aussitôt afflué sur le marché du Trésor après que le rapport a été publié, le prendre comme un signe que l'économie ne va pas en traction réel où il compte mettre les gens au travail.
Je ne semble pas avoir quelque chose en commun avec eux. Si un morceau de technologie sensibles dans Star Trek, c'est l'ordinateur principal du navire, qui n'a pas vraiment été exploré, sauf peut-être un peu sur TOS. En raison des règles de HTML d'éléments implicitement fermés, cette erreur peut créer des effets en cascade.
Ensemble, la secousse amaigrissant et biscuits peuvent être utilisés pour remplacer un repas ... Ils seront Mont Blanc Stylo d'abord vous aider à déterminer votre marché cible. Travail à faire qqch bonne chaque jour, se concentrer sur quelque chose. Je ne suis pas de droite noyau dur, ni de gauche.
- http://lijiani.bj146137.idc-123.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=2187164
- http://enseignement-lsf.com/spip.php?article64#forum24445260
- http://www.dailyqr.com/blog_entry.php?user=1081841&blogentry_id=18196178
- http://chancegardner.backstagemamas.com/guestbook/index.php?entry=41592
Air Jordan Femme 143 km
The Foundation does not give medical advice or engage in the practice of medicine.. The worldrenowned Sanyo Denki Ball bearing fans are made of the Air Jordan Femme highest quality components to ensure maximum quality and performance. Water line program always be definitely therapeutic for your job when you are a plumbing engineer.
Designing symbolic which identifies the maker is often a very personalized trip. He was the one who started it. Throw it now. The book's "not about the crazy extreme things," says Potter, who studied computer science and visual art at Brown University.
Eventually after 7 months of no success in stabilising me, we tried Lithium Carbonate. Vibram Soldes On that note, two friends and I decided to start our own digital innovation company. This is a pretty darn good consolation prize. TTYL :)I may have been one of those players, and you bet it was fun.
Benefits: Incredibly fast, agile sportsman with regard to their dimension. Search Facebook and other social networking sites like mySpace , Linkedin, Xing, Wikipedia profiles and much more.. Just leave a comment here on this post and I will email the files to you..
But now reports suggest that both Inter and AC Milan are keen on the 26yearold. Thomas (Honolulu, Hawaii), Kenneth A.. The fact that kids are signing over all the rights to their articles for like $50100 is BULLSHIT. As a college student fortunate Christian Louboutin Paris enough to go to school by the beach, keeping the oceans plastic free is a cause near and dear to my heart. Longchamp Soldes
And minimal increase last one year 25 each eye. Singh, P. CI would give a temporary licence (up to ten years ) to Galway County Council who would then oversee the project.. This news release contains forwardlooking statements that involve risks, uncertainties and assumptions.
Once you buy the camera which suits you best, you are probably going to want to check out the training video to get you Nike Free Run 2 Pas Cher started to great images in no time.. When they old enough, give them a little money to buy a new food (also a great way of learning numbers and costs) .
If you' re wondering about SSD that don't support TRIM, here's some info:"No TRIM, but Garbage CollectionThe IBIS drive features a fourcontroller internal RAID, and there currently no way to pass TRIM along to drives in a RAID array, which means its very .
After viewing the beautiful valley of Dirang overlooking the river and inhabited by colourful tribals, proceed towards the Sela Pass (13703 ft) spend some lovely times by the paradise lake and overnight at Tawang (143 km, 7hrs ). The first time you did my glasses and your wife suggested to me that I also have my lenses tinted to gently soften the lines around my eyes was a very memorable experience..
- http://gamesvisit.com/activity/p/344659/
- http://www.cpefound.org.php5-14.dfw1-1.websitetestlink.com/node/13#comment-331538
- http://lab.nqnwebs.com/lavoz_bak/spip.php?article5818/
- http://www.juegosetnicos.com.ar/spip.php?article86&lang=zh/
Ceinture Gucci abondent.
Tous les miens vivent à l'extérieur, sauf pour les plus jeunes. Le petit Ceinture Gucci qui est à l'intérieur est dans un vivarium dans une partie de la maison que de a beaucoup de trafic, et tout le monde interagit avec lui tout le temps, lui offrant une friandise quand il est sorti de la clandestinité, mais je ne laissez personne le manipuler . Il sait maintenant quand quelqu'un passe par de venir et obtenir un morceau de fruit ou Mont Blanc Stylo Pas Cher d'un autre traitement, donc il est très sympa sans être manipulé.
Brown comprend une capture d'écran de ce que cela va ressembler comme vous le faites. Par exemple: Étape 1: Ouvrez le Bloc-notes et tapez les balises HTML, comme indiqué ci-dessous: alors il ya une capture d'écran de bloc-notes avec ce que cela va ressembler quand vous tapez les informations. Et nous ne sommes qu'au chapitre 3 en ce moment et il ya 20 chapitres en tout.
Vérifiez la table des matières à choisir des activités qui répondent à vos besoins et désirs. Chaque ressource a été évalué et classé par les spécialistes basés dans les universités du Royaume-Uni. Didacticiels Google Earth sur des sujets illimitées (mathématiques, littérature, culture, géographie, lecture, écriture, et encore) abondent.
Dans la première guerre des Boers l'uniforme britannique composée de la robe de bure, qui était écarlate pour l'infanterie et ingénieurs, vert foncé pour les fusils et bleu pour tous les autres. Pantalon bleu foncé ont été portés avec un passepoil rouge long de la couture pour l'infanterie et Louis Vuitton Chaussures une large bande rouge pour l'artillerie, avec des bottes en cuir noir. Régiments Highland portaient des kilts écossais au lieu de pantalons..
Certains d'entre eux étaient beaux Nike Free Run 2 caractères et il était profondément bouleversant de voir comment nous les traitons. Lorsque nous emprisonner des innocents nous rendre malades, et quand nous les expulsons c'est souvent une condamnation à mort. Je savais que je devais écrire à ce sujet, parce que c'est un secret Lunette De Vue Chanel sale.
Sydney Aquarium de Sydney Aquarium est situé à Sydney Darling Harbour. Sydney Aquarium présente une vue fascinante sur le monde sous-marin, qui comprend plus de 12.000 animaux aquatiques de 650 espèces, des crocodiles d'eau salée et tortues de mer géantes. Sydney Aquarium présente le plus grand Grande Barrière de Corail exposition et incroyables tunnels de vision sous-marine avec les requins et les raies qui nagent au-dessus de votre tête et vos enfants vont adorer le bassin tactile et le sanctuaire des mammifères marins.
- http://bbs.ytlongkou.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=1246739
- http://ouseburncc.co.uk/docs/node/6729#comment-256503
- http://www.buylocaluk.co.uk/forum/suggestion-box/135218-nike-air-max-femme-la-theorie-atomique.html#135908
- http://www.film-video-dvd-production.com/spip.php?article6/
Gucci Ceinture les médias ont pu parler du prix des DRAM
La page doit être renommé. Therestaurant a été touché et il est devenu une caractéristique intégrale de tous les magasins IKEA. Voir boophilusannulatus. Il s'est approché de moi à Gucci Ceinture 15 heures le vendredi pour me dire qu'il venait juste de commencer à faire des progrès sur une présentation dont il a besoin pour lundi matin.
Puis elle fouilla une balle hors des limites et a pris un tir court que a été brutalement rejeté.. Vous cherchez à acheter, nous pouvons vous montrer toute la maison à vendre à Onslow County via notre accès à la MLS (de Multiple Listing Service). Cela se sent vraiment next gen et vous pouvez vraiment voir comment il allait changer l'acte de regarder la télévision pour de nombreuses personnes.
À agir ou les consommateurs ou Gucci Ceinture Pas Cher quelqu'un d'autre pour faire le travail pour eux », dit-il. Acceptent la plupart des modèles de téléphones mobiles et la fermeture velcro maintient votre téléphone sécurisé dans le support. Ce genre de test est extrinsèque à l'apprentissage réel et applique un programme strict qui n'est pas flexible pour les intérêts et les besoins des élèves aussi.
'Blow ce pour une alouette (ou rire)' serait encore être compris ici, bien que nous soyons plus nombreux ces jours-ci à utiliser 'vis' plutôt que Tiffany Pas Cher de 'coup'.. Le livre aura défauts visibles, mais pas graves. Ils ont tous dit qu'ils justifiées pour protéger les Noirs d'être stigmatisés.
'Radio Rewrite' était la capsuleuse en une amende tout programme Reich par le New York alarme ensemble Will Sound, présenté par Stanford en direct (qui a commandé le nouveau travail). En outre, pour éviter envahissement, ils ont aussi demandé que seuls les appelants authentiques utilisent les lignes téléphoniques d'urgence ...
Dans le passé, les médias ont pu parler du prix des DRAM, surtout quand il y avait une nouvelle Windoze O / S qui une fois de plus exigé beaucoup plus de RAM juste pour faire fonctionner le bloatware .. IAV travaille également sur l'optimisation des moteurs électriques industriels, ce qui les rend plus léger, moins cher et plus économes en énergie ...
Non, elle ne mourra pas en ce moment. La pauvreté, répandue dans les bidonvilles de la périphérie de la ville, a conduit à New Balance 574 des taux élevés de criminalité, la drogue et la prostitution .. The Everly Brothers étaient le seul groupe parmi les premiers intronisés au Temple Rock and Roll of Fame en 1986 ...
J'ai plié dans votre café-balles et cétoniques chou Polo Ralph Lauren Femme Pas Cher régimes d'agitation pour aider à briser une perte de poids plateau autour de la Journée 45 ou plus.. En quelques clics rapides, vous pouvez vous acheter un pot de beurre d'arachide en poudre, une arbalète, une paire de cuissardes, et un sac de quarante livres de chat précieux Ultra litière agglomérante Cat premium..
- http://verdamilio.info/org/spip.php?article573/
- http://mariettakaramanli.fr/spip.php?article602/
- http://general.assembly.codesria.org/spip.php?article87&lang=pt/"/
- http://www.phyll.com.cn/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=734844
Stylo Mont Blanc Pas Cher 250 and 500 fils .
Often when a price is quoted the unit will be omitted, so if you're told that something is 25, it's a matter of working out whether it's 25 fils, 25 piastre or 25 dinars! Although it sounds confusing, most Jordanians wouldn't dream of ripping off a foreigner.Coins are 10, 25, 50, 100, 250 and Stylo Mont Blanc Pas Cher 500 fils .
W enot only try to give our clients the visual comunication tools they need to be competitive, but to stand out from among the crowd. So instead of just having a photo of a widget, you can put a description with your important keywords. Indians have amazing advancement.
He was given vitamin C and cough medicine. I need to prove that there is an avenue of Research which has shown GREAT promise it needs one more step to reach the cure and Vibram Soldes yet No research groups has taken this step because of a "Technicality" their stubbornness into going beyond this route despite the clues or evidence .
This will help users better find content relevant to their search. We were encouraged to build "relationships" with customers to get to know their regular patterns (esp. Then after it loads go to File > Save As and choose Trace File.. Or find a buddy who lives in your apartment complex.
Information from the CBS affiliate in New York City, including the identity of the gunman the news that this started as an attack by a fired employee at his former Abercrombie Paris place of work:.. The product would benefit consumers who seek to remove small scars and patients with seriously disfiguring scars..
What can i say am a bit mental who is very hyper and always cracking myself up.I am at perth college full time studying business which is really hard but good banter! Currently work at JJB its sooo boaring but can be a laugh depending on who is working..
The first was in "camouflage", but even in that it looked good. The first few were high school students competing in the teen competition.. Cord. The NutriSystem diet plan started in 1972. Each post is from a random different country. Surgery and peels are sure to be costly; ranging from 000, painful; often resulting in swelling , formation of sores, dryness, peeling, and burning, and time consuming; with recovery times averaging about a week..
This is an effective time and people tested principle. Now going into 2011, GM has a new marketerinchief (Joel Ewanick, previously of Hyundai fame), and he is touting Ray Ban Pas Cher a philosophy that removes mention of GM and redirects attention onto the specific model or brand.
Connect to the right audiences with PR Press Services. Each article is a page of information, which is linked with other related pages and external links, allowing you to quickly obtain information, Air Max 1 Pas Cher and more importantly, edit, add to, and discuss that information for the benefit of the scientific community...
- http://verdamilio.info/org/spip.php?article573/
- http://www.dp1234567.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=2446256
- http://ks35439.kimsufi.com/spip.php?article450/
- http://verdamilio.net/tonio/spip.php?article1678/
Nike Tn Pas Cher and Italian Courts
That usually when the conversation ends, or another talking point. I love how this little hit piece acts like Alex Jones is so outrageous for suggesting the towers came down with explosives, Hey HuffPost sorry to break it to you, now the Japanese legislature, and Italian Courts (along with a host of other governments, including Venezuala and Iran) have both openly discussd that explosives had to have been used on 91101 , but if you dont believe them then maybe you should look into Architects and Engineers for 911 truth, where nearly 2000 explosives experts, certified architects and engineers have Nike Tn Pas Cher signed a petition agreeing that explosives had to have been used to take down all 3 buildings that came down that day ( yes you probably didnt know that 3 buildings came down while only 2 where hit with planes) .
Gambling outweigh the initial. A host is basically a very fast computer or generally stored in a data centre with very good connections to the fiber networks.. Thus the existence of God came in and in his Fred Perry Pas Cher virgin mind that is how God was created by man His existence began since then..
Not only will it convince people to purchase the item however it will definitely grab their interest and make them have to discover out additional regarding the item... Be that as it may, the closures of it that go over your ears might be better. Early on when taking stimulants, the effect is an increase in Nike Shox Rivalry Pas Cher the production of adrenaline.
Mike Hermes Ceinture Pas Cher is also the founder and on the steering committee of Coadec, the Coalition for a Digital Economy, which works to lobby for legislation that fosters a sustainable and innovative digital economy for the UK. I Nike Free Run 2 am still waiting on that call. This was ahead of all other Canadian schools as well as large American ones like Berkeley, Cal State and UCLA..
Fortunately, the act of file sharing will by no means be illegal . On this week's show:Gene and Chris present Gabe Valdez's son Greg, who has just released a very informative book, "Dulce Base: The Truth and Evidence from the Case Files of Gabe Valdez," which provides a fascinating look at his dad's many years of investigative work in and around the Dulce, NM/Rio Arriba County region .
For that reason, I changed stylists at one point to see someone who was available for my schedule. Did people refuse to buy Kindles because books were tied to your Amazon account? Nope. When diagnosed with brain cancer (GBM) March 31, 2011, Wayne's response was "we'll fight this"; and he did, living the words he so strongly believed, "never give up"..
- http://heliygroup.com/index.php?option=com_kunena&func=view&catid=3&id=103167&Itemid=84&lang=en#103167
- -pour-moi-chaque-jour-de-ma-vie.html#37831 http://www.merexmarkets.info/forum/trading-platform/37831-nike-air-force-1-un-ami-que-je-n-ai-même-pas-reconnaître-a-été-là -pour-moi-chaque-jour-de-ma-vie.html#37831
- http://www.73pinche.com/forum.php?mod=forumdisplay&fid=2&filter=typeid&typeid=3
- http://www.expo-2015milan.com/activity/p/544913/
Ralph Lauren Femme
The service is still populated by social media early adopters, the same group that was first on Twitter. It is this spirit that the German poet Heinrich Heine sang of when he wrote that once the peapod bursts open, the sugar peas inside are for everyone to enjoy.".
Therefore, nootropics should be regulated like any other medicinal drug in order to lessen the likelihood of abuse and harm.. We estimate that this website earns at least $5 USD per day with advertising revenues so it can be valued at least $4 642 USD.
And Southwestern School of Law announced plans to offer a certificate for nonlawyers in Bioscience Industry Law and Practice... It's a fun place to write with a strong community who can help you succeed.My most recent content site is Zujava.. April 27, 2013 Sat Apr 27 00:00:00 PDT 2013 Eddie Lacy slipping all the way to the Packers at No.
Ideally this would suit someone retired or looking for casual on call style work. He recalled a boy in a coffee shop asking a friend, "What do you want to do tonight, Marty?" The friend simply responded, "I don't know , Angie, what do you wanna do?""As a little kid I thought it was the most amazing thing I had ever heard in my life," Levinson said..
The Project (Project Th Purojekuto?), also known as Toho Project or Project Shrine Maiden, is a series of manic shooters made by Team Shanghai Alice whose sole member is Japanese game maker ZUN, who does all the graphics, music, and programming.[1] The Project began in 1996 with the release of the first game, Highly Responsive to Prayers, Ralph Lauren Femme developed by .
Do not fall into the trap of thinking that more cores is always better. You can join forums that are relevant to your niche and start contributing to it. Delay Not too bad, Louis Vuitton Evidence Pas Cher but I don't know if people . Some will just turn to the high cost I personally believe that there are no known side effects all of which are Ceinture Hermespas Cher extreme and sulfur.
While the price of the PS4 is something that has yet to be determined, some reports point to the company's alleged plans to start mass production of the device in Q3 2013... Xsite pro comes with more than 100 templaets, but if you want greaphics that are just right for you, then you may have to go to a professional.
Making Nike Paris other people happy is easier to accomplish than trying to make yourself happy, and the result of this success is you guessed it, happiness!.. If you Ray Ban Lunette De Vue wish to reprint this on your own website, simply click the "Web Version" in the right menu, and you are presented with a preformatted document to use.